For the Minister of Land Reform and Rural Development to review

The Ministry has not yet seen this page. It describes the office only through what the law says, what the Ministry has said or done, and what others named here have said about it. The DevForum has not approached the Ministry about anything. Until the Ministry has approved the text, it may change. Questions for the Ministry:

  1. Is this description of the Minister’s role on Farm 39 correct? What would you like to change?
  2. Does the Minister still hold the Remainder of Farm 39 in trust, and has any notice been published for Farm 39 since the transitional period ended in 2011?
  3. Has any power under TRANCRAA for Farm 39 been delegated to the Premier of the Western Cape or to a provincial official?
  4. Which office in the Ministry or the department handles Genadendal, and should readers reach it through the moderators or through a public contact?

The Minister of Land Reform and Rural Development is the member of the national Cabinet responsible for land reform [IC]. Under the Transformation of Certain Rural Areas Act (TRANCRAA), the Minister holds the Remainder of Farm 39 in trust for its residents and makes the final decision on which body will receive it [IC]. This is a national office. It is separate from the Western Cape Department of Agriculture, which is a provincial department, and from the national Minister of Agriculture [IC]. Since July 2024 the Minister has been Mzwanele Nyhontso [IC]. The Minister works through the Department of Land Reform and Rural Development [IC].

What the letters in square brackets mean

Facts on this page are followed by a tag that shows where they come from.

  • [IC] Independently Corroborated. Confirmed by an official record, such as a law, a government notice, or a court or council record, or by at least two sources that do not depend on each other.
  • [MS] Mission-Sourced. Comes from the organisation’s own website or statements, from the statements of a group it works with, or from the DevForum’s own records. It has not been checked against sources that do not depend on them.
  • [TBV] To Be Verified. Seems likely, but nobody has confirmed it from a reliable source yet.

At a glance

KindGovernment (national Cabinet office)
MinisterMzwanele Nyhontso, since July 2024 [IC]
Deputy MinisterStan Mathabatha [IC]
DepartmentDepartment of Land Reform and Rural Development
Role on Farm 39Trustee of the Remainder, and final decision-maker on its transfer [IC]
Contact with the DevForumNot approached

Why this Minister, and not the Department of Agriculture

TRANCRAA was passed in 1998. It gives its powers to “the Minister for Agriculture and Land Affairs”, the name of the portfolio at the time [IC]. Since then the portfolio has been renamed several times, and the powers have stayed with the Minister responsible for land reform [IC].

YearsName of the portfolio
1996 to 2009Agriculture and Land Affairs [IC]
2009 to 2019Rural Development and Land Reform [IC]
2019 to 2024Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development [IC]
2024 to nowLand Reform and Rural Development [IC]

In mid-2024 land reform and agriculture were given to two separate Ministers [IC]. The department behind them was split in two, and the split was finalised on 1 April 2025 [IC]. TRANCRAA went with land reform: in the 2026/27 budget vote, Minister Nyhontso reported on land transferred from the state to communities under the Act [IC].

The Western Cape Department of Agriculture is a provincial department. TRANCRAA does not name it [IC]. The Act does let the Minister delegate powers in writing to the Premier of a province, such as the Premier of the Western Cape, who may pass them on to a provincial member of the Executive Council or official [IC]. Whether this has been done for Farm 39 is not known [TBV].

What the office does on Farm 39

  • Holds the land. Trust land that has not been transferred when the transitional period ends “vests in the Minister”, who may keep holding it in trust and transfer it later under the Act’s principles [IC]. The transitional period for Farm 39 ended in January 2011 without a transfer, so the land stayed with the Minister [IC].
  • Decides who receives it. The Remainder may go to the municipality, a Communal Property Association, or another body the Minister approves [IC]. The Minister may transfer it only once satisfied that the receiving body’s rules balance the rights of residents, members, and users [IC].
  • Recognises the residents’ committee. The Act defines an elected committee as one “which has satisfied the Minister that it represents the majority” of residents [IC].
  • In court. In 2008 the Genadendal Transformation Committee, the Minister of the day, and the municipality signed an Agreement of Settlement that the High Court made an order [IC]. In 2014 the Committee asked the Land Claims Court to find that the municipality and two Ministers had breached that order [IC].
  • Letters from the municipality. In September 2016 the Municipal Manager wrote to the department asking the Minister to decide on a receiving body [IC]. In September 2022 the DA’s Western Cape spokesperson on human settlements said the municipality had written twice to the then Minister, Thoko Didiza, about interim basic services and land use at Madiba Park, and had received no reply [MS].

Relevance to W2DF

What is still open

  • Whether any notice for Farm 39 has been published since the transitional period ended in 2011.
  • Whether any TRANCRAA power for Farm 39 has been delegated to the Premier of the Western Cape.
  • Which office in the Ministry or the department handles Genadendal, and how residents can reach it.
  • Whether, and when, the Minister will decide on a receiving body for the Remainder.

Have your say

If you know more about the Minister’s role on Farm 39, contact the moderators via How to Submit.

References