This idea is not yet agreed. Nobody named on this page has been asked about it: the Genadendal Transformasie Komitee, the trustees of Die Bevryde Grond Trust, Cullinan & Associates Inc, Theewaterskloof Municipality, and the national Department responsible for land reform. Because it deals with Farm 39 land, it goes to the Transformasie Komitee in writing first. It can be tabled at a DevForum meeting once the Komitee responds, or 21 days after it was sent, whichever comes first. Please do not share this page publicly yet.

What the letters in square brackets mean

Facts on this page are followed by a tag that shows where they come from.

  • [IC] Independently Corroborated. Confirmed by at least two sources that do not depend on each other, or by an official record.
  • [MS] Mission-Sourced. Comes from the people putting this idea forward, or from the trust deed this page describes. It has not been checked against other sources.
  • [TBV] To Be Verified. Seems likely, but nobody has confirmed it yet.

Statements without a tag are proposals. They describe what the idea could become.

The goal

Hold the land of Farm 39 and Erf 595 in a form that no one can sell or mortgage, so that the argument about who owns it can give way to agreement on who cares for it.

Why the valley needs it

The Transformation of Certain Rural Areas Act of 1998 (TRANCRAA) provides for the Remainder of Farm 39, mostly commonage and farmland, to pass from the national Minister to an entity [IC]. The Act names the municipality and a Communal Property Association (CPA), or another body the Minister approves [IC]. The Minister may only transfer the land once satisfied that the receiving body’s rules balance the tenure and use rights of residents, members, and present and future users [IC].

The process for Farm 39 began in 2002 [IC]. Its 18-month transitional period ended in January 2011 without a transfer, so the land stayed with the Minister [IC]. The record on TRANCRAA and Farm 39: The Land Transfer Process shows the parties divided on several points that bear on this idea:

  • Municipality or community entity. The municipality recommended itself as the entity in 2010 and 2016 [IC]. The Transformasie Komitee is setting up a CPA to receive the land [MS].
  • Land sales during the process. The 2008 court order placed “an immediate moratorium on the sale of Trust Land” [IC]. The Ward 2 Forum’s 2017 analysis says over 200 residential properties on Farm 39 had been sold and transferred [MS].
  • Whether new owners will look after the land. In October 2024, 82% of South Africa’s 1,742 registered CPAs were not complying with the law that governs them [IC].

The Ward 2 Development Forum agreed on 16 September 2026 that other platforms already deal with the TRANCRAA process, and that it will avoid duplicating them [MS]. This page is therefore offered to the Komitee as an idea for its consideration. It does not propose that the DevForum take part in the process itself.

The trust deed

Die Bevryde Grond Trust (“the Freed Land Trust”) was first set up on 14 September 1995 as the Leerkrans Trust, which owns a farm called Hoekiesdam in Wolseley, WC [MS]. Its founder and trustees adopted a new deed in October 2012 “to create a vehicle to conserve and safeguard access to land for public benefit”, and renamed the trust [MS]. The copy held by the DevForum bears the stamp of the Master of the Western Cape High Court, dated 15 November 2012, and the stamp of Cullinan & Associates Inc [MS]. Cormac Cullinan, a director of that firm, helped draw up the deed [MS].

The deed’s main provisions are these:

  • Custodian in perpetuity. The trust’s vision is “to be the custodian in perpetuity of land that is in its care, for the benefit of those who are able and willing to accept the responsibility of working and caring for the land” [MS].
  • Land made available to those who care for it. The trust’s primary object is to make its land available “to those who are willing and able to protect and care for it in perpetuity” [MS]. Anyone given the right to occupy or use the land must conserve its ecosystems, and anyone who farms it must use agro-ecological practices [MS]. The trust must prevent its land being degraded by urban and other development [MS].
  • No sale and no mortgage. The trustees have no power to transfer ownership of the trust’s land, or to mortgage, pledge or encumber it in any way [MS]. The one exception is a transfer to another owner, which needs all the trustees to agree that the land will go on being protected and used in line with the trust’s vision [MS].
  • Clauses that cannot be changed. The clauses setting out the vision, the objects and the ban on sale “shall not be capable of amendment” [MS]. Other clauses can be amended by 75% of the trustees [MS].
  • No private gain. No trustee may acquire any right in the trust’s assets, and no assets may be paid to a trustee except as reasonable pay for services or repayment of costs [MS]. If the trust ends, its assets may pass only to another public benefit organisation, a tax-exempt body with public benefit aims, or the state [MS].
  • Consensus first. The board decides “in preference by consensus” [MS]. It goes to a vote only if all trustees present agree that a decision is imperative [MS].
  • Disputes go to mediation. A dispute between trustees goes to a mediator within 15 days, and to binding arbitration if mediation fails within a further 15 days, through the Arbitration Foundation of Southern Africa [MS].
  • Nominations from outside. Before appointing a trustee, the trustees must ask named organisations to nominate candidates, though they need not appoint those nominated [MS]. There must be between three and seven trustees [MS].

The deed’s preamble says private land ownership “fosters a culture of trading land as if it is a mere commodity” and “distorts how people relate to land and natural communities” [MS]. Our Long-Term Goal makes a related point: problems start “when money decides who gets land or water” [MS].

How it could help with Farm 39

The deed was written for a single farm in private hands, and nothing in it was designed for TRANCRAA. It offers two things the valley could use.

As a set of clauses. Whichever entity receives the land, its founding rules could borrow the deed’s strongest provisions: a ban on selling or mortgaging the land that no later vote can remove, conditions of care attached to every right of use, consensus decisions with mediation and arbitration when consensus fails, and assets that can pass only to another public body. A CPA’s constitution, or the agreement under which a municipality holds land in trust, could carry clauses of this kind. This route leaves the choice of entity where it is.

As the receiving entity. TRANCRAA allows the Minister to approve a body other than a municipality or a CPA [IC]. A trust on these lines, with the residents of Farm 39 as its beneficiaries, could be put to the Minister as that body. It could also sit alongside a CPA, for example holding the commonage and farmland while the CPA holds other rights. Either form would put the land beyond sale by any party, including the entity itself.

Each route speaks to one of the points in dispute. A permanent ban on sale would answer the concern behind the 2008 moratorium. Conditions of care, built into every lease, would link a right to use the land with a duty to look after it.

What the deed would need before it fits

The deed in its present form would not meet TRANCRAA’s test, and could not be copied as it stands:

  • Rights over the land. The deed bars the trustees from granting “any option, lien, restriction, right to acquire, right of pre-emption, third party right or interest or security interest of any kind” over the trust’s land [MS]. That would rule out the registered rights described under What residents would hold. A Farm 39 version would need to allow registered leases and use rights for residents, while keeping the ban on selling or mortgaging the land itself.
  • Who appoints the trustees. The present trustees appoint new ones, after consulting named organisations [MS]. TRANCRAA requires rules that balance residents’ tenure and use rights [IC]. A Farm 39 version would need residents to elect or confirm trustees, and a way to remove them.
  • Trustees’ discretion. The deed gives trustees “a complete and unfettered discretion” over the assets, and frees them from giving reasons for their decisions [MS]. Residents would need written rights the trustees could not override.
  • Public benefit or residents’ benefit. To keep its tax status, the trust must carry out its activities “for the benefit of the general public” [MS]. Farm 39 is held in trust for its residents [IC]. A lawyer would need to say whether one trust can do both, or whether the valley would need a different form.
  • Existing rights. Users of the garden plots and holders of farm leases would each need a settled place in the new arrangement, as would the owners of properties already transferred off the farm.

What residents would hold

Many residents want a title deed to the land they live on and use [TBV]. A trust that can never sell its land cannot hand out freehold deeds to all of it. It could still give households secure, registered rights, and in some forms it could sit beside full title. The routes below are proposals for discussion, and each needs a lawyer’s opinion before it is put to residents.

Title for homes, the trust for the commons. Under TRANCRAA, trust land inside a proclaimed township passes to the municipality [IC], which could then give households title to their erven. The trust would hold only the Remainder, mostly commonage and farmland [IC]. It would then never stand between a family and the deed to its house. This route touches the oldest point in the dispute. The 2008 court order says “there shall be no distinction” between the inner and outer commonage [IC], and the Komitee holds that the whole of the land is subject to TRANCRAA [MS]. It could only be raised with the Komitee as a question.

Registered long leases on trust land. The trust would keep the land, and each household would hold a long lease or use right registered in the Deeds Office. The right could be inherited, and sold to another qualifying resident, and it would bind anyone who later controls the trust. The consultants’ lawyers concluded in 2010 that users of the garden plots already hold registerable use rights [MS], so the record offers a starting point. Whether banks would lend against such rights is not known.

A choice for each household. Residents who want full title to their residential erf could take it. Those who prefer the protection of the trust could place their plot in it, or hold a lease from it. The trust could hold a right of first refusal when a titled property comes up for sale, so that land returns to common care over time.

Properties already sold. The Ward 2 Forum’s 2017 analysis says over 200 residential properties on Farm 39 had been sold and transferred [MS]. Their owners would keep their title, and the trust would hold only land that remains unsold. That sets aside the question of who would undo those sales.

People who arrived after 1998. TRANCRAA counts as a resident anyone who ordinarily lived in the area on 2 November 1998 [IC]. A trust could offer leases to later arrivals whom the community accepts, without changing anyone’s status under the Act. The Ward 2 Forum’s 2017 series proposed that people who arrived later and are “in good standing” may be considered as beneficiaries [MS].

Conversations it could open

Even where the trust is not the answer, raising it could start conversations the process has lacked.

  • With the Komitee, about what a title deed is for. Residents may want security of tenure, the right to leave land to their children, the right to borrow against it, or the right to sell. Some may want protection against outsiders buying in. Freehold title gives most of these, along with the risk of land passing to outsiders. A registered lease from a trust gives several of them without that risk. Asking which matter most to families, perhaps through The Yearly Valley Survey, would move the talk from who owns the land to what households need from it.
  • About the history of the land. In 1858 the land was granted in trust to the church’s superintendent as sole trustee, and many residents rejected the grant, holding that the land had belonged to their Khoi ancestors [MS]. A trust whose trustees are chosen by residents would reverse that arrangement. Seen this way, the idea mends the 1858 trust, and could be heard in the valley on those terms.
  • With the municipality, about rates and services. The municipality’s 2025 Financial Recovery Plan records that in Genadendal “the community feels that the land does not belong to the municipality and that they therefore have no obligation to pay for said services” [IC]. Clear, registered rights for each household could give both sides a footing for an agreement on rates and services.
  • With the Department, about the third route. Asking whether a trust controlled by residents could be approved under TRANCRAA would test the Minister’s discretion without anyone setting aside the CPA.
  • With funders. Land that can never be sold, held by a public benefit organisation and conserved by its users, is the kind of asset that conservation and outcome funders back. This links the idea to Ridge to River to Table: Investing in the Whole Valley and From Water Access to Water Agency.
  • Towards 2038. Genadendal turns 300 in 2038 [IC]. Land that will still belong to the valley at the tricentenary is a goal residents could hold to, whatever legal form carries it.

Who would benefit

The residents of Farm 39, as the TRANCRAA process defines them, and the people who farm or graze its land. The land itself would be protected against sale and development.

Who would pay

Nothing has been costed. A legal opinion would cost money, as would drafting a deed or constitution and consulting residents as TRANCRAA requires. No one has offered to pay.

Who would decide

The Minister decides which entity receives the land [IC]. The municipality, or failing it a committee elected by residents, recommends the entity [IC]. The Transformasie Komitee speaks for residents in the process [IC]. The DevForum has no role in that decision [MS].

How it fits the DevForum’s goal

The idea touches the Conservation and Environment priority, through conditions of care on all land use, and the Agriculture and Food Sovereignty priority, through secure access to land for those who farm it. It also bears on the Civic sphere’s value of equality in Our Long-Term Goal, because land that cannot be bought cannot pass to whoever has the most money.

What is still open

  • The Komitee’s view. Whether the Transformasie Komitee wants to consider this idea at all, given its work towards a CPA. It has not been asked.
  • The DevForum’s decision of 16 September 2026. Whether tabling this page at the DevForum fits that decision, or whether it should go only to the Komitee.
  • The trust’s consent. Whether the trustees of Die Bevryde Grond Trust agree to their deed being described here. They have not been asked.
  • Cormac Cullinan’s view. Whether he or his firm would advise on a version for Farm 39. Neither has been asked.
  • The law. Whether a trust can be approved as a receiving entity under TRANCRAA, and whether a trust for residents can also be a public benefit organisation.
  • The municipality’s and the Department’s views. Neither has been asked.
  • Residents’ wishes. How many residents want freehold title, and how many would accept a registered lease or use right. Nobody has asked.
  • Leases and lending. How long leases and use rights on trust land would be registered, and whether banks would lend against them.
  • The inner and outer commonage. Whether the Komitee would discuss treating residential erven differently from the commonage, given its position and the 2008 order.
  • How the trust deed has worked. How Die Bevryde Grond Trust has run since 2012, and whether it registered as a public benefit organisation as it intended [MS].

What happens next

  1. The moderators send this page to the Transformasie Komitee in writing.
  2. The trustees of Die Bevryde Grond Trust are asked whether their deed may be described on this site.
  3. If the Komitee wishes, Cullinan & Associates Inc or another lawyer is asked for an opinion on the two routes above.
  4. The page is tabled at a DevForum meeting once the Komitee responds or 21 days after it was sent, whichever comes first, unless the Komitee asks that it go no further.

Have your say

To comment on this idea, see How to Submit or raise it at the next DevForum meeting.

References

  • Die Bevryde Grond Trust. Deed of Trust in respect of Die Bevryde Grond Trust (formerly the Leerkrans Trust). Signed 11 October 2012; Master’s stamp dated 15 November 2012; certified copy dated 2 April 2013. Held by the DevForum. The trust’s history, vision, objects and rules.
  • Ward 2 Development Forum. TRANCRAA and Farm 39: The Land Transfer Process, and the records it cites. The state of the process and the points in dispute.
  • Ward 2 Development Forum. Inaugural Meeting, 16 September 2026. The DevForum’s decision on the TRANCRAA process.