This idea is not yet agreed. Nobody named on this page has been asked about it, including the Transformasie Komitee, Theewaterskloof Municipality, national Departments, the Western Cape Government, the Moravian Church, CapeNature, the Greyton Ratepayers and Residents Organisation, and the residents of Madiba Park and Heuwelkroon. Please do not share this page publicly yet. It goes to the Komitee in writing, and to a DevForum meeting once the Komitee responds or 21 days after it was sent, whichever comes first. At that meeting, anyone can question it, change it, or reject it.

What the letters in square brackets mean

Facts on this page are followed by a tag that shows where they come from.

  • [IC] Independently Corroborated. Confirmed by at least two sources that do not depend on each other, or by an official record.
  • [MS] Mission-Sourced. Comes from the account of the party the fact is about, in its own documents or statements. It has not been checked against other sources.
  • [TBV] To Be Verified. Seems likely, but nobody has confirmed it yet.

Statements without a tag are proposals. They describe what the idea could become.

The goal

Development in Ward 2 has stalled. Drawing on the valley’s history and on its conversations with residents and organisations, the DevForum would propose what must happen first for each party, and ask each one to correct it.

Why the valley needs it

Challenges: The Record and the Present State sets out where the valley’s challenges came from and where they stand in 2026. Much of what it records has remained stuck for years:

  • The Remainder of Farm 39 is still held in trust by the national Minister, 28 years after TRANCRAA came into force, and no receiving body has been recognised [MS].
  • The municipality’s spatial plan says it “is not allowed to invest in infrastructure, where the Municipality is not the owner of the land” [IC].
  • Electrification for Madiba Park was budgeted at R1.6 million and cut in February 2023 [IC]. The R10 million for building homes on Erf 595 was removed in February 2026 [IC].
  • Genadendal’s share of the municipality’s debtors rose from 23.0% in October 2025 to 23.7% in May 2026, and it currently stands at R108m [IC].

The record shows what happened. Read together, it also points to what has to change before each matter can move. Nobody has yet set that reading out in one place, where every party can see it and test it.

The idea

The DevForum would take on a new role: proposing, for each party, what appears necessary before progress can be made. Its proposals draw on the historical record on the Challenges page and on conversations the DevForum’s convenors have held with people and organisations in the valley [MS]. Each proposal is the DevForum’s reading, and the party it concerns may reject it.

The DevForum would send each party its row, in writing and in the language the party prefers, with two questions:

Does this match your reading? What would you change?

Each response would be recorded in the party’s own words, dated and tagged [MS], and the party would approve the wording before it is published. A disagreement stays on the page beside the proposal it answers. Where a response shows a proposal to be wrong, the DevForum would revise the proposal and note the change. Until a party responds, its cell would read “Not yet asked”, or “Sent on (date), no reply yet”.

When most parties have responded, the DevForum would read the responses together and note where two or more parties agree on what must happen first. Those findings would go into the second research run on the Challenges page.

The table

The second column comes from the Challenges page, which gives the sources. The third holds only what each party has said in public. The fourth is the DevForum’s proposal, and carries no tag. The fifth is for each party’s response.

PartyWhat the record showsWhat they have said so farWhat appears necessaryTheir response
Residents of the Farm 39 villages: Genadendal, Bereaville, Voorstekraal and BoschmanskloofNo resident of the Remainder can hold title to land there until a transfer happens [MS]. The municipality may not invest in infrastructure on land it does not own [IC].At the DevForum’s first meeting, Genadendal participants and the Komitee raised “the longstanding nature of the process” and “the ability of the community to utilise its land and associated resources effectively” [MS]. They said affected communities “should be involved from the beginning of proposals” [MS].The Remainder of Farm 39 passes to a body residents recognise, with a settled answer on who counts as a beneficiary. Until then, an agreed way for services and investment to reach the settlements.Not yet asked
Genadendal Transformasie KomiteeElected by residents on 9 November 2004 [IC]. Its court application of 2007 ended in a 2008 order with “an immediate moratorium on the sale of Trust Land” [IC]. In 2025 it began setting up a Communal Property Association to receive the land [MS].In 2024 an office-bearer told GroundUp that the community had set up a CPA and was waiting for the Department to finalise it [MS].The CPA is registered, or what stands in its way is made public. The Komitee and the municipality find a way of working together that both can work with.Not yet asked
Residents of Madiba ParkIn January 2019 the chemical toilets were removed and the water was cut off [IC]. Electrification was cut in 2023 [IC], and the Erf 595 building budget in 2026 [IC].A resident, 2024: “When it comes near to the time, nothing happens, we protest and then they promise the same thing” [MS].A written answer on where residents will live and when, including whether they are on the beneficiary list for the Erf 595 homes. Basic services in the meantime, agreed with the Komitee.Not yet asked
Households moved to Heuwelkroon, and their familiesUnder the Group Areas Act, coloured families in Greyton, many of whom owned plots and small farms, were forced to sell and leave, and most were moved to Heuwelkroon [IC]. Sources differ on the dates [TBV]. How many households were moved, and whether a land claim was lodged, has not been found [TBV].An essay in Herri, written after talking with Greyton residents, says “a community of subsistence farmers who owned their own farms were overnight reduced to having to work as gardeners and domestics for white people” [MS].The removals are acknowledged in public by the bodies that speak for Greyton today. A record is made of how many households were moved and whether any claim was lodged.Not yet asked
Greyton Ratepayers and Residents OrganisationGreyton was a freehold village with title deeds, and a municipality from 1910 [IC]. Whether Erf 595 is the Greyton commonage is still open [TBV].No public statement by a Greyton or Heuwelkroon residents body on Madiba Park was found.Its records on the commonage, the leiwater rights and the removals are shared with the DevForum. It states its own position on Madiba Park and Erf 595.Not yet asked
Descendants of the first peoples: the Soaqua, Chainoqua and HessequaFrom 1669 settlers took the grazing land at the Huis River, where Greyton stands, as free to take [IC]. Smallpox in 1713 killed many Khoekhoe, and more settlers moved onto their land [IC].Who speaks for them on this page is for the DevForum to agree.The DevForum agrees who speaks for them. The valley’s account of its own history records the taking of their land in the terms they choose.Not yet asked
The Moravian ChurchBalie’s history says the 1909 Act gave the mission title to its church, school and houses [MS]. Title to the Glebe Lands was granted free of charge to the Church in 1927, and they sit outside the TRANCRAA process [IC]. Residents brought land cases against the mission at the end of the 1800s and in 1924 [MS]; the outcomes have not been found [TBV].No statement by the Church on these matters was found.The Church makes public what it holds on the Glebe Land title, the Bereaville portions and the land cases, so residents can see which land lies inside the TRANCRAA process and which lies outside it.Not yet asked
Theewaterskloof MunicipalityIt began the TRANCRAA process on Farm 39 in 2002, through consultants it appointed [IC]. Genadendal held 23.7% of its debtors in May 2026 [IC].2016: “a hostile environment has over the years developed between the TWK and the Transformation Committee” [MS], with “the Rates boycott and the poor collection rate in Genadendal” as the first issue to resolve [MS]. 2024: it could not provide full services at Madiba Park because “the settlement is not on municipal land” [MS].A settled answer on whether residents of TRANCRAA land are liable for municipal accounts, reached through a facilitated process on the Genadendal accounts. See Citizen-Led Recovery for Ward 2.Not yet asked
Department of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural DevelopmentThe national Minister holds the Remainder of Farm 39 in trust [IC]. No receiving body has been recognised [MS].In 2024 its spokesperson said “certain issues” were still outstanding [MS].The outstanding issues on Farm 39 are named in public, with a timetable for the transfer.Not yet asked
Western Cape GovernmentIt intervened in the municipality under section 139 of the Constitution on 11 November 2024 [IC], authorised 333 homes on Erf 595 on 10 July 2025 [IC], and approved the Financial Recovery Plan on 7 October 2025 [IC].The Recovery Plan says: “Genadendal is particularly challenging as services are rendered and billed, but the community feels that the land does not belong to the municipality and that they therefore have no obligation to pay for said services” [IC].Ward 2’s own evidence is heard in the monitoring of the Recovery Plan. The Erf 595 homes have a funded start date.Not yet asked
CapeNatureThe Moravian Church bought Langgezocht in 1899 to protect Genadendal’s water sources [MS]. When and how it and the other mountain farms passed to CapeNature has not been found [TBV].No statement on this was found.A public record of how the mountain farms passed to CapeNature, and an agreement with the valley on how the water sources there are protected and used.Not yet asked

Who would benefit

Every party would see the DevForum’s reading of every row, and could answer its own. The DevForum’s champions would know which conditions stand in the way of their priority before they start work on it.

The money

Nothing has been costed. The work would take moderators’ time, translation, and meetings in the villages where no single body speaks for residents.

Who would decide

The DevForum would decide what it proposes in each row, who is asked, and who speaks for groups that have no single body. Because the table deals with Farm 39 land, the Transformasie Komitee would review the Farm 39 rows first. Each party decides its own response and approves how it is recorded.

How it fits the DevForum’s goal

The DevForum agreed at its first meeting that affected communities should be involved from the start [MS]. This idea would put the DevForum’s reading in front of them before any project is planned on it. It serves Our Long-Term Goal and all five DevForum Priorities, since each priority meets the conditions set out in the table.

What is still open

  1. Who speaks for the descendants of the first peoples. For the DevForum to agree.
  2. Who speaks for Madiba Park residents and the Heuwelkroon households, where no single body holds a mandate. One route would be a meeting in each place, with the DevForum’s proposal read out and the responses read back before they are recorded. Another would be a question in The Yearly Valley Survey.
  3. The Ward 2 councillor. Local government elections are set for 4 November 2026 [IC]. Whether the councillor’s office gets a row, and when to ask, is open.
  4. Other parties. Commercial farmers and landowners in the valley, and the Breede-Olifants Catchment Management Agency on water rights, may need rows.
  5. How a proposal is agreed. Whether the convenors or a DevForum meeting agrees the wording of each row before it is sent.
  6. Responses given in confidence. What the DevForum does when a party responds but asks that its response not be published.
  7. Each named party’s view of this idea. None has been asked.

What happens next

  1. The page goes to the Transformasie Komitee in writing, with the Farm 39 rows marked for its review.
  2. It is tabled at a DevForum meeting once the Komitee responds or 21 days after it was sent, whichever comes first. The DevForum agrees the proposal in each row, who is asked, and who speaks for each group.
  3. The moderators send each party its row, with the right-of-reply contacts already planned for the Challenges page.
  4. Each response, once the party has approved its wording, is added beside the proposal with the date.
  5. When most parties have responded, the DevForum revises its proposals, and its findings go into the second research run.

Have your say

To respond to the DevForum’s proposal for your organisation or community, or to name a party that is missing, see How to Submit or raise it at the next DevForum meeting.

References